Texas law requires property to be taxed equally and uniformly. That gives homeowners a second way to win a protest: instead of arguing what your home would sell for, you show that the district values your home higher than comparable homes. If the comparison holds up, you can win even when your market value is about right.
The test the board applies
Under Tax Code 41.43(b), a protest for unequal appraisal is decided in the owner's favor unless the district establishes one of three things. For a single home, the practical one is (b)(3): that your appraised value is equal to or less than the median appraised value of a reasonable number of comparable properties appropriately adjusted.
Read that carefully. The burden is on the district. You bring comparable homes and their district values, adjusted to your home; if the median comes out below your value, the district has to show otherwise.
On appeal to district court, Tax Code 42.26(a)(3) uses the same comparison: relief is available when your appraised value exceeds the median appraised value of a reasonable number of comparable properties appropriately adjusted.
Building the comparison
- Pick comparables. Homes in your subdivision or on your street, similar in size, age, construction and lot. Five is a good number; avoid homes with obvious differences you cannot adjust for.
- Pull their values. From the district's property search, for the same tax year. Use the market value for each, including for capped homesteads: Tax Code 42.26(d) says comparisons use the market value the district determined, not the capped value.
- Adjust each to your home. Size, age and features, the same way you would adjust a sale. Adjustments must follow generally accepted appraisal methods (23.01(f)), so keep them simple and consistent.
- Take the median. Line up the adjusted values and take the middle one. Compare it with your value.
Why this works well for homeowners
- You do not need sales. The data is public and every home has a value.
- The district's own numbers are the evidence, which is hard for it to dismiss.
- It works in neighborhoods with few recent sales.
Watch for
- Cherry-picking. A panel will notice if every comp is the cheapest house on the street. Choose honestly similar homes.
- Unadjusted comparisons. A 1,600 square foot comp is not proof that your 2,100 square foot home is overvalued. Adjust first.
- Next year. If your value is lowered at protest, the district may not raise it the next year unless the increase is supported by clear and convincing evidence; after an unequal appraisal reduction it can meet that by showing the inequality has been corrected (23.01(e)).
The packet's Equal Appraisal page does this math for you and states the 41.43(b)(3) test on the page. Add your comparables.
Common questions
Where do I find my neighbors' appraised values?
In your appraisal district's online property search. Values are public. Search by street name and pick homes like yours.
Can I protest unequal appraisal and market value together?
Yes. Form 50-132 combines them in one box: incorrect appraised (market) value and/or value is unequal compared with other properties.