Skip to content
Not a government site.Not affiliated with any appraisal district. Filing a protest with your district is free. You pay only for the prepared packet.
Protest My Appraisal
Menu
Guide

Property tax protest evidence that works

What an appraisal review board can act on, and how to present it so the panel follows your numbers.

An appraisal review board can only lower a value when the evidence in front of it supports a lower number. Opinions ("my taxes are too high", "the market has cooled") do not move panels. Numbers they can check do. Here is what works for a home, in rough order of strength.

1. Comparable sales, adjusted

The market value of a home is what it would have sold for on January 1. The most direct proof is what similar homes actually sold for around that date. Texas law shapes what counts:

  • Timing: a sale is generally not comparable if it happened more than 24 months from the valuation date, or 36 months for a residence in a county over 150,000 people (Tax Code 23.013(b) and (b-1)).
  • Similarity: comparability is judged on location, lot and building size, age, condition, access, amenities, views and legal burdens like easements (23.013(d)).
  • Method: comparables and adjustments must follow generally accepted appraisal methods (23.01(f)).

Raw sale prices rarely line up, so adjust each sale toward your home. A comp with 160 more square feet sold for more partly because it is bigger; subtract the value of that extra space. A newer comp gets adjusted down for age. A comp with a pool you lack gets adjusted down for the pool. Then take the median of the adjusted prices. That median is your strongest single number.

Size adjustment rate. Appraisers usually adjust size at well under the full price per square foot, because land and kitchens do not scale with square footage. The packet defaults to half the median price per square foot and shows the rate, so the panel can see exactly what you did and change it if they disagree.

2. Equal appraisal comparables

You can also win by showing your home is valued higher than similar homes, even when the market value is defensible. The board must rule for you unless the district shows your appraised value is at or below the median appraised value of a reasonable number of comparable properties appropriately adjusted (41.43(b)(3)). The district's own property search gives you every neighbor's value. See the unequal appraisal guide.

3. Condition, with bids

Districts usually value a home as if it is in typical condition for its age. If yours had a failing roof, foundation movement or water damage on January 1, a buyer would have paid less. Bring written bids or estimates from contractors, dated photos, and a short list tying each photo to an item. A repair total subtracted from the median comp value is easy for a panel to follow.

4. The district's own evidence, checked

Ask for the district's evidence when you file. It must provide it free, on request, at least 14 days before the hearing, and anything it failed to provide may not be used against you (41.461, 41.67(d)). Look at its comparables: are they adjusted, in your neighborhood, close in time? Weak district comps are part of your case.

5. Errors in the record

Check the district's description of your home: square footage, bathroom count, pool, garage, quality grade. A wrong fact is the easiest fix there is. Bring a survey, a floor plan, or photos.

How to present it

  • Lead with a one-page summary: noticed value, your value, and what each exhibit shows.
  • Label exhibits with tabs and refer to them by letter.
  • Bring enough copies; some districts ask for three to five sets. Check your county page.
  • For a phone, video or affidavit hearing, send evidence with a notarized Form 50-283 before the hearing starts.

The protest packet builds all of this from what you enter, with the adjustment math shown on the page.

Common questions

How many comparable sales do I need?

There is no fixed number in the Tax Code. Three to five well-matched sales are easier for a panel to follow than ten loose ones.

Can I use Zillow estimates?

Automated estimates are opinions, not sales. Use actual closed sales and the district's own values instead.

Do I need a professional appraisal?

No, but one helps. If your property is worth $1 million or less and you deliver a certified appraisal at least 14 days before the hearing, the district must prove its value by clear and convincing evidence (Tax Code 41.43(a-1)).

Turn your evidence into a packet the board can follow

Enter your values and comparables once. Preview every page free. Pay only if you want the clean PDF.

Start my packet freePacket $29 · with hearing prep kit $39 · filing with the district is free